A trooper detained by ICE in Wisconsin became this week the clearest example of a very common misunderstanding: having a work permit is not the same as having immigration status. At Campos Law Firm, we closely monitor developments in U.S. immigration policy to protect our clients’ rights and future. The case of Carel Aaron Van Der Merwe, a Wisconsin State Patrol trooper, has its own details that cannot automatically be applied to every asylum applicant.
Here is what we know, what we do not know yet, and what you can do.
What Happened to the Trooper Detained by ICE?
On Thursday, November 5, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers arrested Van Der Merwe at Dane County Regional Airport in Madison while he was waiting to board a domestic flight. According to ABC7 Chicago, he was taken to the Dodge County detention facility. He is 21 and has been a trooper since July 13, 2025, according to local media and the Wisconsin Department of Transportation.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) called it a “targeted enforcement operation” and said the trooper entered the country legally in March 2019 with permission to stay until September of that year, but overstayed. His attorney, Marc Christopher of Christopher & De Leon, said the young man came from South Africa as a child, is included on his father’s pending asylum application, and holds federal work authorization valid through 2030. The family, he said, has waited seven years for an asylum interview.
According to his legal team, when he showed his work permit, the officers said they “did not care.” On the night of November 6, the law firm said he would be released under an order of supervision, and FOX 11 later reported that he had left the detention facility.
Why Does DHS Say He Had No Legal Status?
“To be clear: work authorization or a pending application do not confer legal status in the U.S.,” a DHS spokesperson told WMTV. The statement reflects a real distinction in immigration law:
- Work permit (EAD): the Employment Authorization Document issued by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) lets you work legally. It is not a visa or a green card, and on its own it does not stop ICE from starting deportation proceedings.
- Pending asylum application: it lets you stay while your case is decided and generally keeps you from accruing “unlawful presence” for certain penalties. But it is not an approved status; if DHS places you in proceedings, the asylum claim continues before a judge.
- Immigration status: the legal standing the government grants you (a valid visa, approved asylum, permanent residence, TPS). That is what actually protects you from deportation.
In other words, Van Der Merwe could work legally, even as a police officer, and still not have an approved status. That does not make him automatically deportable: he is now in removal proceedings and has the right to present his asylum case in Immigration Court.
What Does It Mean to Be Included in Your Father’s Asylum Case?
When a parent applies for asylum, they can include their spouse and unmarried children under 21. If the parent wins, the included children also receive asylum. In general, the law protects children who were under 21 when the application was filed, even if they turn 21 while waiting, but every file needs a careful review.
The problem is the wait. A family that waits seven years for an interview lives in limbo: they can work, study, and build a life, but without final status. If a relative of yours is detained, the ICE detainee locator is the first tool for finding out where they are.
Is It Risky to Fly With a Pending Case?
This case does not mean every asylum applicant who flies will be detained. But it is a reminder that airports are places where ICE can act. Before you travel, keep in mind:
- Domestic flights: your work permit is an ID the TSA accepts, but showing it does not prevent an arrest if ICE is looking for you. Talk to an attorney before a trip if you have a visa overstay or another risk in your history.
- International flights: leaving the U.S. with a pending asylum case without advance parole is generally treated as abandoning the application. It can also trigger 3- or 10-year bars if you accrued unlawful presence.
- Carry copies, not your only originals: work permit, Form I-589 receipt notice, and your attorney’s phone number.
- If you are stopped: do not sign anything without advice, say you have a pending case, and ask to speak with your attorney.
Protect Your Immigration Status with Campos Law Firm
A valid work permit is valuable, but it does not replace a strategy for reaching stable status. We do not make unrealistic promises: we provide serious legal representation backed by preparation and integrity. Our team of immigration attorneys can review your asylum application, your documents, and the risks before you make a decision, such as a trip.
Do not leave your immigration status to chance. Call us today at +1 (844) 922-6767 to schedule a free, confidential consultation in English or Spanish. Campos Law Firm: Legal Solutions in All Areas of Law.
With information from WMTV, WBAY, ABC7 Chicago and FOX 11.

